Watchers UFO Archive

UFO case file · UFO-39727

BENNECOURT (78) 08.03.1978

CE1FR1978-03-08

BENNECOURT (78), Ile-de-France, FR

Open this case in the interactive Atlas

Case description

GEIPAN continues to publish all its archives on its public website www.geipan.fr. Its publications include older cases classified at the time as A, B, C or D that are now being re-examined solely to improve the accuracy of their conclusions. New technical tools (software) and the investigative experience gained over the years sometimes lead to new observations or even a change in classification. This observation case, formerly classified C for lack of information and named BONNIERES SUR SEINE (78) 1978, is among the cases recently re-examined. On 8 March 1978 at 06:45, a female motorist saw lights of various colours through woodland, coming from a field. On reaching the field, she saw a very shiny metallic grey-blue object shaped like a large upturned bowl. Stationary and silent, it emitted flashing lights around its base. Frightened, she left after 1 minute but returned at noon with work colleagues, who found a circular impression on the ground at that spot. The gendarmerie learned of it through public rumour the next day, contacted her and visited the site. It found no particular traces other than a tractor’s. The witness said many curious visitors had trampled the area. GEIPAN makes a preliminary methodological distinction for cases whose accounts or traces concern a phenomenon explicitly described or perceived on the ground: - Unless it is shown that the phenomenon could only have arrived or departed by air, the search for an explanation exceeds GEIPAN’s expertise alone. GEIPAN can give a conclusion only if proof or near-proof is established; otherwise it must classify C: unassessable because it exceeds GEIPAN’s expertise alone. - If an exclusively aerial arrival or departure is established, absence of accounts or traces of its off-ground phases may still prevent a conclusion for lack of reliable information, the usual GEIPAN C classification. This is the first situation: nothing excludes arrival or departure along the ground. Examination of the field traces proves nothing either way. GEIPAN consequently classifies C: unassessable because it exceeds its expertise alone. Within the limits of its expertise and experience, GEIPAN offers this analysis: - The visual description has moderate strangeness. - It is compatible with a vehicle with lights in a field near the road before daybreak. Darkness and the unexpected presence of a vehicle at that time may have encouraged misidentification. - The witness’s immediate sense of strangeness appears limited: she stopped for only 1 minute and did not wait to see what happened. She did return, perhaps also prompted by her colleagues’ reaction to her flying-saucer hypothesis. A vehicle’s presence at that time would nevertheless be surprising and form the main anomaly. GEIPAN suggests a possible illicit activity such as poaching, while stating that this cannot be verified. Above all, the observation has weak evidential substance in both information and reliability: - Neither the principal account nor the colleagues’ secondary accounts were volunteered; the gendarmerie requested them. - The phenomenon’s development or disappearance was not observed. - The gendarmerie did not find circular or suspicious traces. - Perceived unusual traces and collective excitement among colleagues and journalists may have increased the witness’s sense of strangeness and influenced her later statement. - The colleagues’ non-spontaneous accounts give minimal, almost identical descriptions of the traces, leaving an unverifiable possibility of prior coordination or influence.

Recorded details

Local time
06:45
Coordinate precision
Source-provided or normalized location; precision not increased beyond source.
Date precision
day

Sources and further reading

Browse more UFO case files