UFO case file · UFO-39753
BIERRE-LES-SEMUR (21) 18.07.1978
BIERRE-LES-SEMUR (21), Bourgogne, FR
Open this case in the interactive AtlasCase description
GEIPAN continues to publish its entire archive on www.geipan.fr. Older cases originally classified A, B, C or D are being reassessed solely to improve the conclusions. This case, previously classified D and named PRECY SOUS THIL (21) 18.07.1978, is among those recently reassessed.
Around 04:00 during the night of 17–18 July 1978, a camper saw a stationary luminous phenomenon low in the sky. He described an orange ball shaped like a saucer or upside-down plate and took 3 photographs before it disappeared southwards, slowly at first and then rapidly. He heard no sound. The Gendarmerie found no other accounts nearby, and developing the photographs yielded nothing.
GEIPAN considers the fiery orange colour and low south-western position characteristic of a setting celestial body (see the investigation notes). Temporarily setting aside the final southward motion gives a strong explanation: Stellarium places the Moon at azimuth 240°, exactly the direction of Dompierre-en-Morvan from Lucenay, attributed to the initial UAP position. Its 2° elevation fits the low, fiery appearance of a reddish setting Moon. Forming clouds could reveal part of the Moon through gaps in many shapes, including the reported one.
The final southward movement is poorly documented. It remains compatible with a cloud gap moving south, or appearing to move south from a 240° sightline. The day’s wind was generally eastward, although no 04:00 data are available. Relative to that sightline, its movement could have an unnoticeable component towards the witness and a perpendicular component perceived as southward.
The close agreement between the Moon’s actual position and the UAP’s position and appearance makes the explanation probable. What little is known of the final movement does not contradict it. GEIPAN distinguishes the witness’s visual perception from his interpretation through fatigue and surprise, attributing the mistake to the latter.
Under GEIPAN’s current classification, the slightly unusual case is B: probable misidentification of the Moon.
Recorded details
- Local time
- 04:00
- Coordinate precision
- Source-provided or normalized location; precision not increased beyond source.
- Date precision
- day