Watchers UFO Archive

UFO case file · UFO-40403

BESSINES-SUR-GARTEMPE (87) 05.10.1993

CE1FR1993-10-05

BESSINES-SUR-GARTEMPE (87), Limousin, FR

Open this case in the interactive Atlas

Case description

GEIPAN continues to publish all its archives on its public website, www.geipan.fr. These publications include older cases, classified at the time as A, B, C or D, that are now being reexamined solely to improve the relevance of their conclusions. New technical tools (software) and the investigative experience gained over the years sometimes lead this reexamination to new observations or even a change of classification. This sighting, previously classified D and named BESSINES SUR GARTEMPE (87) 1993, is among the cases recently reexamined. On 5 October 1993 at about 18:20, several people in a garden near woodland saw colored lights appear in a clearing. After a few moments they heard a thunder-like sound and saw a flash of lightning. The luminous phenomenon in the clearing disappeared. Reexamination establishes the following: - The accounts use terms commonly associated with thunderstorms: lightning, thunder, detonation and so on. - Arguments against a thunderstorm are unconvincing: “It was not a thunderstorm because ... there would not have been just 1 bang,” and “the lightning went one way and the bang or noise the other.” - The apparently strangest feature, lights in the woods, was never verified as actually originating there because the witnesses abandoned their plan to go and look. It could therefore have been successive lightning flashes seen through the trees. The viewing position near the vegetable garden is on the southern slope of a dome-shaped hill, Puy de Sarran. The lights were perceived at “the northernmost clearing,” near the summit. Woodland mainly covers the slopes, descending 10 m per 70 m. Lightning beyond the northern or northwestern horizon of the hill could be seen through only a limited depth of trees because the woodland canopy is dome-shaped, appearing at the clearing's surface. There are no trees on the hill's eastern side. A witness could see the clearing directly, unobstructed by trees. The lights appearing 4 m above the ground in the clearing further reduces the depth of trees their light would cross before reaching it. - The Limoges weather service, asked by letter about 18:00 without contextual information, reported nothing unusual at that time and did not broaden the time window. The Sauvagnac radio-relay station, however, reported heavy rain, distant thunderstorms and lightning in several directions from 20:00, without giving an assessment for 18:30–19:00. GEIPAN considers this highly compatible with preliminary thunderstorm activity—a few flashes and a single thunderclap—30 minutes or 1 hour earlier, 12 km farther north. These are the source's stated times and interval. - The witnesses were friends, apparently in a cheerful or animated mood. Each had consumed 3 beers and a pastis that afternoon before the sighting (see official report). GEIPAN suggests this might have facilitated sharing or amplifying their sense of strangeness. - It may seem surprising that the gendarmes did not notice a thunderstorm from their premises 2 km away. The hill could have hidden distant lightning beyond it; in any event, flashes are not always noticed indoors. A bang “like an explosion or thunderclap” was heard from T4's home, which is closer to the garden, 1 km away, and north of the hill, therefore nearer the supposed thunder source and without any potential acoustic screening by the hill. A thunderstorm cannot be established with certainty, but GEIPAN assigns this hypothesis a probability above 50% from the evidence as a whole. The complete absence of angular measurements of the lights' directions and their durations weakens the accounts, which are borderline unassessable. GEIPAN therefore classifies the case B: thunderstorm.

Recorded details

Coordinate precision
Source-provided or normalized location; precision not increased beyond source.
Date precision
day

Sources and further reading

Browse more UFO case files